Tag Archives: Anti-Depressants

Yes Virginia, Psychiatric Medication Does Work.

By Marvin Ross

As I’ve said so many times, anecdotes are not proof of anything but I am going to use one to demonstrate the efficacy of anti-depressants. The anti-medication people do nothing but give anecdotes of the dangers of psychiatric medications and the difficulties some have going off them. When research is cited, they usually attack it as being biased and/or funded by big pharma.

Research does show that for most and when prescribed properly, these pharmaceutical agents do help. As an example, I’m the power of attorney for someone with Alzheimer’s Disease. When he was first being assessed by a family doctor, he came out as being depressed on the Beck Depression Inventory. While he was under going evaluation, he was given anti-depressants which he only took rarely.

However, when he had his diagnosis confirmed by the geriatric psychiatrist, it was recommended that he go back on and stay on the anti-depressant to help with both his depression and his anxiety. In order to ensure compliance with that and the Alzheimer’s med, he was given a weekly blister pack. The pharmacist loaded the pills for each day and for the proper time.

He saw the psychiatrist a few months later and was assessed again on the Mini Mental Status Exam (MMSE). The psychiatrist noted that not only did he appear more relaxed and less anxious than at the previous session, but that his dementia score had improved slightly – not because his dementia was better but because he had less anxiety.

Then, a few months later, the home care co-ordinator showed up to do a reassessment. She called me amazed. My friend, she said, was far more relaxed and showed no signs of anxiety or agitation which were evident when she first assessed him. As she said, “he still does not know where he lives or what the date is, but he is very relaxed about everything”.

Yes, this is an anecdote that and not a definitive study but it is an example of the benefit of this class of drugs. For a list of the meta analytic studies done for anti-depressants that do show efficacy, visit this webpage. Check out the home page on that site for other resources. Thanks to Robert Powitzky for pointing me to it.