Some Thoughts on Parenting and Parent Blaming.

By Dr David Laing Dawson

I read R. D. Laing years ago. He was a good writer, a poet, and unfortunately good writing can hide a bad argument. At the time I thought there was one glaring problem with his thesis, and that was, that if we are to believe that the parenting style, the behaviour of the parents, especially the mother, was entirely to blame for the child’s woes, or even schizophrenia, and therefore was BAD, as in “she is a bad mother”, then logically we could trace her badness to the behaviour of her parents, and then to their parents and on through the lineage.

So with that logic, if it were true that all of one generation’s woes can be traced to the behaviour of the parents, there was no blame to be assigned, except perhaps to Adam and Eve. And as I recall, with every theory of motherly behaviour causing schizophrenia being discussed in our study groups, (Laing’s conspiracies, double bind, skew and schism, the schizophrenogenic mother) someone would say, “Don’t all mothers do that?” And we would laugh at this obvious truth. For to be a parent means to be sometimes overprotective, sometimes a bit neglectful, sometimes too preoccupied, sometimes angry, sometimes demanding, sometimes in disagreement, sometimes short tempered, sometimes too tolerant, sometimes offering conflicting advice, sometimes playing on guilt, sometimes encouraging, sometimes discouraging, sometimes right and sometimes wrong.

On the other hand there is nothing to stop brutal, immature, even sociopathic teens and adults from having children. Some terrible things do happen to children. In this part of the world we have imperfect systems in place to discover this, to intervene, and to apprehend if necessary. The worst of these situations often go undetected for years, for by their very nature, they are secretive, antisocial, and sometimes very mobile. And the children who suffer through this are often scarred for life.

The systems to protect children will continue to be imperfect, for to perfect them would require a level of state surveillance and interference our society would not tolerate. But we can continue to do our best, discuss it, adjust our laws and processes, rescue many, and try to help others recover.

Professional Parenting advice changes with every decade, as often as other fads and fancies. It often follows the zeitgeist of the time, and usually echoes the current advice or wisdom found within other human endeavours, such as best management practices in the new information industries. Fortunately most parents ignore this formal advice and seek the guidance of their own common sense, knowledge of child and teen behaviour and development, and the wisdom of their own parents, aunts and uncles. And most parents struggle to find the right balance, the right expectations, the right levels of support, love, acceptance, control and discipline.

But I don’t think we are biologically programmed to thrive, at least after age 3 or 4, within a cocoon of family perfection and complete safety. We need some challenge and adversity; we need some things to overcome, some fears to conquer, some skills to acquire. We need some adversity in our childhoods and adolescence. We need to experience failure, at least once or twice. We need to experience the death of a pet, perhaps a grandparent. We need to skin our knees, get lost and find our way home. We need to do some things that cause us anxiety. We need to experience disappointment. We do not need perfect parents.

But one child’s adversity may leave scars while another child’s proves to be the cauldron for a very successful life. Barack Obama is only one of several US presidents who lost their fathers by death or abandonment in childhood.

To paraphrase an actor/comedian who gave the Commencement address at his Alma Mater, The University of Western Australia: “You are all very lucky to be here. Some of you because you were lucky enough to have stable, wealthy parents, who guided you, inspired you, and paid your tuition. The rest of you because you were born with the genetic makeup to overcome whatever obstacles were in your way and get here on your own.”

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Some Thoughts on Parenting and Parent Blaming.

  1. Thank you for these very sensible comments.

    Unfortunately, parent blaming is rampant among many clinicians working with parents of people who have developed psychotic disorders. Parent blaming is essential in the belief system of the powerful alternative movement. They believe social determinants and personal adversity create ‘mental health concerns.’ If patients have obviously come from stable, middle-class homes not impacted by war, poverty, etc., , then bad parents must be to blame. Bad parents can have a grim impact on people as the personal stories of many psychiatric-survivor leaders indicate.

    Unjustified parent blaming has a very negative impact on clients of the mental health system and promotes paranoia in people who are already often dealing with this symptom; as well, these clients rarely receive adequate psycho-education about their disorders. Too often clinicians further alienate their clients with smi from the people who are most interested in and devoted to their well-being.

    Like

    1. Yes Susan, I am amazed at the amount of parents blaming that is out there still.

      R.D Laing was invited to Queen’s decades ago by the psychology Department for the esteemed Grant Hall distinguished guest lecture series . HIs lecture was madly clapped. Even then he embarrassed the psychology Department. He was not only parent blaming, but he claimed that the mad world caused serious mental illness. The fact that he spoke while likely very drunk /drugged or was manic seemed to escape the University crowd.

      An extraordinary show of stupendous nonsense.

      With regard to student behaviour here in 2017 during frosh week, we are witnessing a lot of entitlement and immaturity and yet they are being encouraged to rock on with the dangerous nonsense. Voiding on the streets mid afternoon by boys and girls as well as the usual drinking in order to collapse. This will not result in a mental illnesses like schizophrenia but it might give them some serious problems with alcohol.

      Like

    2. In the middle 80s,I became a volunteer of a wellknown community org. A staff person had come to speak to employees of the company I was working fornteers, I was soon drawn into psychiatric survivor spins, had a hard time hearing their stories, i then ventured into family groups, and started attending family meetings.It soon became obvious that I was hearing the other side of the story of a psychiatric survivor…..Both were very nice persons, but one was full of delusions, the other was distressed by the illness and unable to stand the stress anymore, pilfered bank accoun, demolished car, stolen wares…. and more….
      You’d think that psychaitrists would have been able to recognise deluisons….

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s